Going into more detail on that thought; my perceptions of equating these strategies to business get to be, once again, a little underhanded. I will not concede that they are necessarily wrong though. Sun Tzu’s most preferable option of attacking an enemy’s strategy could be a number of things. One could be advertising. The German commercial seen here,
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2966210832320267059&ei=SyPFSprXHp_oqQLMt-Uv&q=burger+king+mcdonalds&hl=en#
shows how Burger King has gone after MacDonald’s for years. That commercial was actually banned after a lawsuit. Another advertising example would be Buick’s new campaign against Lexus. A commercial seen here,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U50UbFOK5s
attempts to derail the idea of Lexus being the top luxury car brand. Some people might recognize this billboard that’s located on north-bound I-75 coming into Tampa:

The second most preferable option is to disrupt alliances. In business, this could be disrupting your competitor’s supply lines. If your able to convince your competitor’s suppliers to, for some reason, no longer do business with your competitor, you’ve put a serious roadblock in their way. The third most preferable option is to attack their army. The fourth is to attack their cities. Now, in business or interpersonal relationships, I wouldn’t really know how to distinguish between the two. Maybe, in business, your competitor’s army would be their legal division.
The practical equivalent of Sun Tzu’s troop size strategy would be bigger companies buying out smaller companies. There’s not a flawless comparison, though. Sun Tzu discusses what strategy to use when you have five times the troop power of your opponent. Well, if a business is five times bigger than it’s closest competitor, it could easily just buy it’s competitor out. But, it probably wouldn’t because it wouldn’t be worth it. The only time they would want to do that is when there competitor is rapidly growing. When your competitor is stronger, find a weakness or wait for one to present itself, and then capitalize.
The next discussion is that of the general being the protector of the state and keeping the sovereign influence out of the military decision making. In business, distinguishing between the general and the sovereign leader is difficult. It seems to me like the CEO would fill both of those roles. A CFO and other executives and officers, would act as advisers. Decision making, in regards to competition, would rest with the CEO.
Comparing Sun Tzu’s military ideas to more recent events; the first and most obvious one that comes to my mind is the Vietnam War. Sun Tzu stresses that sovereign leaders should be kept out of military decision making. Military decisions should not be made by civilians, politicians, or anyone not wise to the ways of military strategy. Dennis M. Simon’s article “The War in Vietnam, 1965-1968” seen here, http://faculty.smu.edu/dsimon/Change-Viet2.html demonstrates unnecessary sovereign influence on the war. If their wasn’t so much political, public, and media influence on military decision making in favor of approval ratings, the war might have gone very differently. The point is, according to Sun Tzu, the war should have been run by the generals, not by the president.
Getting back to business; there are three things a ruler can do to bring misfortune to the army. Advancing when you shouldn’t, retreating when you shouldn’t, and being ignorant of military affairs. At least two of those ideas can be applied to business. Being more financially aggressive with investment when you don’t have the backing for it will cause much too high of a debt to equity ratio. Being more financially prudent than what you are capable of is going to cause a missed opportunity. Obviously, being overall ignorant of business is going to put a huge strain on your advisors; in which case, they should probably just be running the company in your place. How’d you get there, anyway? Nepotism? That idea doesn’t necessarily apply to business, clearly.
There are five circumstances where victory can be predicted: Knowing when to fight and when not to, knowing how to utilize large and small forces, having united ranks, being prudent, and not being interfered with by the sovereign. The principal of a company should know when to be financially aggressive and when not to, have good morale within a company, and know when not to be aggressive. Being interfered with by the sovereign aligns itself with what I stated earlier. It doesn’t really apply. Knowing how to utilize large and small forces doesn’t always apply either. Normally, when you rank up in business, you wouldn’t find yourself moving back to a position of lesser responsibility. Mercedes and Chrysler were both pretty big before they merged, but obviously one had become weak enough for the other to capitalize. I would argue that this article by Chrysler group, http://www.automotoportal.com/article/daimlerchrysler-to-sell-chrysler-group-to-cerberus puts a positive corporate spin on a situation where those running the show couldn’t handle a consolidated company that big. Then again, it’s probably that the combination of strengths still couldn’t overcome the overwhelmingly weak shortcomings of one under the other. What with the corporate spin, this article is the perfect example of making a big deal seem small.
Sun Tzu concludes with the basic idea of knowing your enemy as well as knowing yourself. This translates to both business and interpersonal relationships. Knowing an opponent or competitor’s strengths and weaknesses allows you to try to avoid those strengths and take advantage of those weaknesses.
No comments:
Post a Comment