Sunday, October 4, 2009

"To say that a general must await commands of the sovereign…is like informing a superior that you wish to put out a fire"

The first line of Sun Tzu’s offensive strategy states that taking a state intact is most definitely preferable over destroying it. Great emphasis is put on this idea. To fight is a last resort. Furthermore, what sets apart a good general from a great general is being able to attain victory without killing.

Victory can be attained without fighting. The most preferable option is to attack an enemy’s strategy. Second, is to disrupt alliances. Third is to attack their army. Last, is to attack their cities.

Disrupting alliances makes your enemy much weaker. They have nothing to fall back on but their own resources. It also makes it so they can’t share strategy. This segues into the next idea of troop size strategy. There are two that I think are most interesting. One is, when you have double your opponent’s troops, divide them. That way they can’t discuss unusual strategy. The other, is when you have weaker numbers, to be able to withdraw. There’s still a chance of finding a vulnerability. No matter what the troop size difference, always be able to elude.

The next thing discussed is the idea of the general being the protector of the state. I’m not so sure this should be in the offensive strategy section.

Sun Tzu states there are three things a ruler can do to bring misfortune to the army. One is to advance when they shouldn’t. Another is to retreat when they shouldn’t. Last, is to be ignorant of military affairs. The point here is that civilians or politicians should not be running an army. This confuses the officers and discredits the ruler in their eyes.

According to Sun Tzu, there are five circumstances where victory can be predicted: Knowing when to fight and when not to; understanding how to use large and small forces; having united ranks; being prudent; and, finally, not being interfered with by the sovereign. I’ll be discussing that one further in my next post.

To conclude, know your enemy and know yourself. Knowing just yourself will give you half a chance for victory. Knowing both yourself and your enemy will assure victory. Not understanding either will assure loss.

No comments:

Post a Comment