Sunday, November 15, 2009

“…at first, be shy as a maiden. When the enemy gives you an opening be swift as a hare and he will be unable to withstand you.”

To my readers, the precious few of you there are: I hope you’ve enjoyed my take on Sun Tzu’s manuscript. I hope you’ve appreciated the insight and learned a thing or two. It takes an open mind to compare two different forms of competition, that being war and business. Also, I have no problem with there being only a few readers. It brings an air of exclusivity to my work. Besides, I’m not selling anything. I’m not making any money.

Personally, I’ve really enjoyed reading and writing about “The Art of War”. I’d been wanting to read it for a while and this blog was a perfect excuse. Even when I was choosing what I wanted to blog on, I was on the fence between the bible, Zen, and Sun Tzu. I’ve also been wanting to read the bible and about Zen for a while, but I have no regrets. There are no guarantees that I will enjoy those other books, but I know I enjoyed this one. It was actually much more enjoyable than I thought it would be. I think it will be the most useful of the three in the short term.

What I’ve tried to do is first put Sun Tzu’s advice into layman’s terms. Then I would try to interpret how this advice would be applicable to business and other situations besides war, while giving my take on how viable the information actually is. I would work section by section of the book. I would also throw some of my favorite quotes in as post titles.

I still have not finished the book. There are only three sections left. I have every intention of finishing, but zero intentions of blogging about it. I’ve considered it. Blogging about what I’ve read has really helped to cement the information in my head. If I’m blogging for my own edification and not for a grade or money, I’ll let it slide. One thing I can say: even if the rest of the book doesn’t stick as well because I haven’t reiterated it, I can definitely see myself reading this book again. I enjoyed it that much, and that’s saying a lot.

Sunday, November 8, 2009

"Know the enemy, know yourself; your victory will never be endangered. Know the ground, know the weather; your victory will then be total"



Accessible ground in business would be similar to a landscape where both you and your competitor have equal, beneficial footing and the only real concern is each other. Indecisive ground would be the exact opposite. This would be where the landscape is very challenging and, oh by the way, you have to deal with your competitor as well. Constricted ground is that which whoever arrives first can man all passes in and out and, thus, will have the advantage. This would be like moving into an open area and making loyal contacts with all suppliers; so much that they wouldn’t do business with any competitors that might move in on you. Distant ground would be like having a competitor across town. There would be no benefit to engaging them in direct competition and no reason to provoke them. An example of this would be Ross Perot nearly buying out Microsoft:



In 1979, Perot employed some of his well-known business acumen and foresaw that
Bill Gates was on his way to building Microsoft into a great company. So he
offered to buy him out. Gates says Perot offered between $6 million and $15
million; Perot says that Gates wanted $40 million to $60 million. Whatever the
numbers were, the two couldn’t come to terms, and Perot walked away
empty-handed. Today Microsoft is worth hundreds of billions of dollars.

Because they weren’t in direct competition, Perot felt that he didn’t need to be too aggressive in his dealings.



Sun Tzu talks about how having insubordinate officers will cause a total dissolve of the army. This is directly relatable to business. If there is no structure to decision making and managers are making decisions based on the rationale that they think their executives are wrong, there are going to be a lot of wrong decisions made by those managers. Wrong decisions are going to lead to a loss of profitability and down the path to insolvency. This can be seen in the case of the W.T. Grant variety store chain:



In the mid-1970s, executives at the W.T. Grant variety store chain, one of the
nation’s largest retailers, decided that the best way to increase sales was to
increase the number of customers … by offering credit. It put tremendous
"negative incentive" pressure on store managers to issue credit. Employees who
didn’t meet their credit quotas risked complete humiliation. They had pies
thrown in their faces, were forced to push peanuts across the floor with their
noses, and were sent through hotel lobbies wearing only diapers. Eager to avoid
such total embarrassment, store managers gave credit "to anyone who breathed,"
including untold thousands of customers who were bad risks. W.T. Grant racked up
$800 million worth of bad debts before it finally collapsed in 1977.
The executives had set strict guidelines on the credit for a reason. When the managers decided not to follow those guidelines, the illiquidity was inevitable.

The last discussion is of the general’s decision to engage based on the terrain. The general must be skilled enough to read the terrain and know what’s going to work for and against him. The decision to engage is based off of what’s best for his country and his men. The general should hold no feelings of personal glory in a potential victory. The same should be said of any boss, manager, or executive. It is under these conditions that the best decisions for the company are going to be made. Sun Tzu goes on to compare the troops to the general’s children. The general must be compassionate but stern. He must also know their capabilities under all conditions. Again, the same could be said for business leaders. I won’t make an analogy to compare the ideas because they are directly applicable.

Saturday, October 31, 2009

"Birds rising in flight is a sign that the enemy is lying in ambush; when the wild animals are startled and flee he is trying to take you unaware."

In “Marches”, Sun Tzu first speaks of taking up position and engagement. It is recommended to take position on high ground and/or, after crossing a river, encamp some distance away from the river. Also, when your enemy is crossing the river, don’t meet them at the shore. Wait for half of their forces to cross and then strike. If it is possible, in business, select a location where your target market outnumbers your competitors. That’s going to be on the interpretation of the proprietor to figure out where exactly that is. It won’t be as easy as just setting up shop on the side of a mountain. It’s going to take a macro or microeconomic struggle for the river strategy to apply. If you can come through a downturn quicker than your competitor (crossing the river), then you have the advantage. Wait for them to get halfway through it, and then capitalize (strike). An extremely evident example of this in our recent financial downturn is Chase’s acquisition of Washington Mutual. Chase had this comment to make:



By the end of 2009, all former WaMu customers can conduct their business at any
of 5,000 branches. At that point, all the branches will be branded Chase and
both Chase and WaMu customers will have access to more branches than they do
today.


We’ll definitely feel the effects here in Florida, because this is Chase’s first venture into this area. They have corporate offices here, but no branches.

It is also recommended to stay away from overgrown brush. Spies and ambushes can arise from them. If your firm is new and not so knowledgeable that it cannot keep up with a large metropolitan area, it might be best to set up somewhere that isn’t so busy. Larger areas are going to have more competition. Other areas may not be so fertile, but, starting out, it will be less to deal with and a better learning environment. Don’t go so far as to set up in a sleepy nowhere. Find an area that’s size compliments your skill and knowledge levels and will grow at nearly the same rate as those skills.

Now, if you want to be really paranoid, take this into consideration: When animals are startled and dust rises in columns in the distance, the enemy is advancing. Animals are like people, right? So, if your coworkers are acting funny around you, be very cautious. They might know something you don’t and it could be your downfall.



To piggyback on that, if your enemy requests a truce, he’s plotting on you. He’s just trying to buy time. If someone wants to cut a deal with you, don’t look at it as a deal. Prepare yourself (again, paranoid).

I caught Sun Tzu contradicting himself. If half of an enemy’s force attacks and the other half retreats, it is a decoy. This may be true. Earlier in the book, advice on your own strategy says to not use all of your forces if they are not all necessary. In the spirit of interpretation, if a company doesn’t commit all financial backing possible to put you out of business, they’re planning something else.

When the enemy’s troops are disorderly, the general has no prestige. When checking a competitor’s financial reports, which is perfectly legal, if you can see that things are in general disarray, the CEO is fucking up. Being generally in disarray would be things like layoffs, projects failing and being dropped, and revenues falling. Altus, a video game producer, had this quote in one of their forums on their website:


The extreme nature of their projected loss appears to stem from their withdrawal
from certain markets, so it may be that their core business of video games is
not in mortal danger, although the reduction in ordinary profits and sales seems
to suggest that they may be in even deeper trouble.


Other video game producers might want to be paying close attention to this. The time to capitalize might be nigh.

Piggybacking on that: Too frequent rewards indicate the general is at the end of his resources and too frequent punishments indicate distress. If a CEO, boss, or manager is throwing many office parties and giving a lot of time off, they might be deceiving to hide the fact that they don’t know what to do in a current situation. Going back to layoffs, they are an obvious sign of business distress.

The section ends with a discussion on your own people. If troops/employees are punished before their loyalty is secured, they will be disobedient. If punishments aren’t enforced, then those troops/employees won’t be worth anything, anyway. It takes a light touch, like a pickpocket or a safecracker.



Sunday, October 25, 2009

“When the world is at peace, a gentleman keeps his sword by his side.”

The nine variables section speaks of the general’s actions in encampment and the general’s character.

Ideas of not encamping in low lying ground could be equated to not setting up shop where the conditions favor your competitor. Not lingering in desolate grounds is being sure to have business in an area where there is a fertile market. Uniting with allies would be like having a strong social network. Fighting in death ground would be not going out without a fight. If there is a possibility of being bought out or put out of business, you might as well risk everything to stay afloat or hurt your competitor.




There are occasions when the commands of the sovereign are not to be obeyed. In the heat of battle, situations can dramatically change quickly. Generals have to think on their feet and make the best, quickest decision for the good of the army without consulting the sovereign or considering their former orders. If you’re the head of a sales team at a conference with strict orders from your CEO, would you always follow those orders? Of course you would. That is only if the situation is as the CEO has predicted. If the situation calls for conflicting actions, you take the initiative. It’s a gamble, there’s no doubt about it. If you’re a knowledgeable leader who is well versed in the ways of your job, you’re probably going to make the right choice. Another part of the gamble is the repercussions from your CEO. If they’re not too proud and see the light of your actions, they’ll appreciate your choice. If they set you up for failure purposely or are just too hard-headed, you’re probably going to be fired, demoted, or at least reprimanded. That’s one of the perks of being educated. You occasionally get to make tough decisions when put in a decision making role. Nobody’s always right.

A Sandeep writes in his blog, “All about business…well almost” about how orders must be followed under tight conditions:




“When an organisation is under extreme pressure — so much so, that one wrong
move can mean its collapse — authoritarian leadership may very well be
necessary.”


This guy is a CEO trainer. A CEO is going to have an idea of how a situation is going to be, but they can’t predict every aspect. It’s up to managers to take a CEO’s orders into consideration and approach each situation with the chance to be flexible and authoritative to adjust to changing conditions.



When engaging in a business activity, all things must be considered. By that, I mean everything potentially beneficial and everything potentially detrimental to your purpose.

There are five qualities which are dangerous in the character of the general. These would be the same for CEO’s, managers, or any bosses. Recklessness will cause an eventual mistake. That mistake could cost money, jobs, or even the company. This is crazy evident in the recent bailouts. Jack Markowitz writes in his article “Reckless CEO pay won’t be tolerated” about how CEO’s were reckless because they had the cushion of being bailed out:




Everybody's wary of the "moral hazard" in enlisting taxpayers as the lenders of
last resort. But if that means the end of good paydays for you, Mr. Executive,
here's a guess that far more prudent lending is going to result.

The article also discusses how much more CEO’s makes than they used to. Constricting their pay back to what it used to be and allowing companies that are “too big too fail” to go under would be a good thing. There are always hungry younger companies ready to pick up the slack and that would place some much needed accountability on CEO’s.

Cowardice will cause hesitance. Hesitance will then cause missed opportunities. Quick temperedness will leave them open to provocation. Keep a cool head. Pride, one of the seven deadly sins, will allow instigation through the questioning of honor. If a boss is duped into taking action when they shouldn’t because a competitor questions their moral responsibility, they better have the financial backing to support that decision. Compassion will cause a reduction in aggression. One who is too compassionate won’t gamble on using a branch as collateral in what could potentially be a cash cow deal, simply because they don’t want to gamble the jobs of the people at that branch.


Sunday, October 18, 2009

"...He who comes later to the scene and rushes into the fight is weary."

Arriving first to a business “battlefield” can have its advantages. There is a perception of readiness and preparedness by arriving first. There can be comfort waiting on a competitor, peer, subordinate, or superior in a board room or office. Conversely, if the situation calls for high anxiety, waiting can give time for that anxiety to build.

When speaking of deployment, the idea can be applied to many situations. First, decide what needs to be done. Then, gather all necessary resources. Next, plan the route. The route, in deployment, could be equated to any plan of action in business or life. The best route to use would be the most direct and the most damaging to your competition. The only time to use an indirect route is to deceive your competitor so that you can arrive to the battlefield first and take advantage of the strategy in the previous paragraph. The most direct route would be the quickest way to achieve your objectives. Causing the most damage is self explanatory. Using an indirect route can be associated with the extraordinary force strategy I discussed in my post, "Apparent confusion is a product of good order; apparent cowardice, of courage; apparent weakness, of strength" :



The normal force is in plain sight of your enemy or competitor, and the
extraordinary force is ready to execute without your competitors’ prior
knowledge.

This is just another form of deception, the key to all warfare.




When employing any strategy, distance and pace are to be considered. Setting a pace that all involved cannot keep up with is going to be detrimental. Then again, moving too slowly is lost time. How much distance covered per day traveling to a battlefield would be like how many hours per day are put in on a business project. Too many hours will cause workers to get burnt out. Too few is also lost time.

Knowing terrain is like knowing all outside conditions. If it involves business with a peer, knowing all about that peer; their influences, their alliances, and their goals would by highly advisable. If you want to expand, know economies, competition, and other conditions of the area you wish to expand in to. Having a local scout for each of these situations is also advised. When dealing with a peer or competitor, work with a current or former employee of that peer or competitor. When expanding, have a local give you a sense of the other locals. Try to find out what their attitudes would be toward different ways you could expand into their area.

Considering the attitudes of your workers and a competitor’s throughout the day would be pretty meticulous. If that’s the way you want to be, good for you. I think it’s a little overkill. The only time I’ve used this strategy is when scheduling my car for maintenance. I go in the morning with time enough that the mechanic is fully awake, but not so late that they’re just thinking about lunch. I never go in the afternoon because I know, when I’m at work and it’s past lunch, unless I’m really busy, I usually only have one thing on my mind. That’s going home.

Sun Tzu’s application was evidently seen during the Tet offensive, as demonstrated in THE TET OFFENSIVE: BATTLE FOR HUE JANUARY-FEBRUARY 1968:

…the Communists launched the main offensive itself in the early morning hours of
31 January 1968, when 84,000 North Vietnamese and VC troops, taking
advantage of the Tet (lunar New Year) ceasefire then in effect, mounted
simultaneous
assaults…
The communists attacked in the morning, when their spirits were high, and during the Tet holiday, when South Vietnameses’ thoughts were not on the war.

Control of two of the other factors is just like getting to a meeting first. Be well prepared. If your meeting is with a competitor who looks very organized, let them start the meeting. Make them show their cards before you show yours.

Sun Tzu suggests not taking bait. How does a general know whether what they’re looking at is bait or a legitimate opportunity? That’s what separates the good from the otherwise. Taking bait will clearly lead you into a trap. Let’s say your competitor announces a product that they want you to directly compete with. Resources immediately go toward developing a competing product. Meanwhile, the competitor announces a new flagship product that’s, well, it’s just great. It’s better than anything they already have or anything you have. All your resources are already tracking on competition for the small fish. You took the bait and got trapped. If you’d been more prudent, this might have been avoided. As well prepared as your competitor was, they deserve to beat you anyway.



If, when doing business with a competitor, they try to back out of any deal, let them. Trying to lock them in will make them desperate. God knows what they’ll do. You never know what kind of recourse they might have until they spring it on you.

"...He who occupies the field of battle first and awaits his enemy is at ease..."

There was only one thing I took out of Sun Tzu’s “Weaknesses and Strengths” section. It was summed up in the first sentence and reinforced throughout the rest of the section. That point is that the first army to arrive to the battle field has the advantage.

The next section, “Manoeuvre,” has much more meat to it. The first strategy is gathering the force and encamping, thereby being ready to deploy. Then, the route is determined. The route should be a combination of the most direct and the most damaging. Indirect routes should only be used to deceive the enemy, thus allowing yourself to arrive to the battlefield first, taking advantage of strategies discussed in the previous section.

The next strategy is deploying in stages. If an entire army is deployed at a feverish pace, only 1/10th will arrive. Not everyone can maintain such a pace. Besides pace, distance is to be considered. A distance that the entire army can cover at a time is set. Sun Tzu loosely suggests about thirty li per day, where one li equals about 1/3 mile.

The terrain should be well studied. Knowing how to take advantage of passes, mountains, forests, swamps, cities, and villages is paramount. Having and taking advantage of local guides is recommended.

Just as in battle, as in deployment, an open line of communication is necessary. These signals are facilitated by banners, flags, gongs, and drums. At night, visual communication will be maintained by torches.

While employing for battle, different factors are to be considered. The attitude of both yours and the enemy’s troops will be sharp in the morning, less so throughout the day, and worst at night, when they’re thinking of home. Attacks should be arranged considering these conditions. This is control of a moral factor. Waiting in good order for a disorderly enemy is control of a mental factor. Waiting comfortably for an enemy that is worn is control of a physical factor. If an approaching enemy appears very orderly, do not engage. This is control of the factor of changing circumstances.

If the enemy has any advantage, wait. Don’t take the bait from a trap. Most definitely do not engage an enemy attempting to escape. This will be like trying to fight a cornered animal.

Sunday, October 11, 2009

“Do not demand accomplishment of those who have no talent” The business man as a cutthroat warrior…

Is it a pre-conceived, prejudiced notion that every business man would sell out their own family to close a deal? I’d say so. If people look at a man in a nice suit and they see a fork-tongued, backstabbing bastard, it’s because they’ve been conditioned to think so.

A lot of movies have the bad guy as a powerful authority figure who is usually the head of a big company. Pretty much any Asian movie or cartoon I’ve ever seen has the bad guys wearing business suits. Jackie Chan’s First Strike is a sound example of this. Michael Moore’s new movie is a perfect segue for me. It’s a movie about real life, where Michael Moore bashes capitalism and American business.

In real life, most of the time when you hear about a businessman in the news, it’s because they did something wrong. That’s because the news is always bad news. The front page story is a Ponzi scheme and the lighter side of the news on page 23 is how JP Morgan Chase’s CEO started an initiative to refurbish an impoverished neighborhood.

Business is very competitive. To get to the top, you have to be very talented, very vindictive, or a combination of the two. So, it’s no surprise that a sizeable portion of upper management are less than reputable individuals. That doesn’t mean that all businessmen are that way. Those that aren’t so aggressive will get stepped on by those that are, and will settle into middle management. I’d argue to say that the majority of businessmen are actually pretty decent people.

If people see businessmen, think about these movies and news stories, and then treat them as such, they’re not giving them a fair judgment.

"Apparent confusion is a product of good order; apparent cowardice, of courage; apparent weakness, of strength"

The idea of army hierarchy discussed in the “Energy” section of the book is easily applied to a business situation. The actual construction of the hierarchy in an organization is going to depend on how those that built the company wanted to design said hierarchy. Some ways that a business is organized can be better suited for larger or smaller companies. The way Sun Tzu breaks it down, it doesn’t matter what size your organization is. I’d argue that this idea is somewhat transferable to business. Morton C. Orman, M.D. writes about ways to avoid stress in a company reorganization: http://www.stresscure.com/jobstress/reorg.html. I bring this up to emphasize the point that a reorganization causes stress to employees. If the company is properly organized to begin with or has a hierarchy that’s adaptive to change, these stresses and growing pains can be avoided. Companies might avoid these problems by being organized more like an army. That’s not always possible, though.

With all the forms of communication available today, the idea of businesses using signals and flags to stay cohesive in their strategy, like an army in battle, is somewhat antiquated. They still use a form of signals, so I would argue that this idea is also somewhat transferable. Sun Tzu explains that the signals keep the army unified in their strategy. All sections of businesses, too, need to stay on the same track. Phone calls, emails, and website updates would be used in place of signals.



Normal forces and extraordinary forces are extremely valid in modern business. To recap, a normal force is your main strategy or offensive maneuver, and extraordinary force is a supplementary strategy or offensive. The combination of these two forces can be used to flank an enemy and assure victory. The normal force is in plain sight of your enemy or competitor, and the extraordinary force is ready to execute without your competitors’ prior knowledge. The extraordinary force backs up the normal force.




For a couple of business examples; let’s say your company has run an advertising campaign against your closest competitor. This would be a normal force. In the mean time, your company is organizing it’s finances and securing loans, unbeknownst to your competitor, to buy them out. This would be the extraordinary force. Maybe you open a restaurant right next to your closest competitor as a normal force. Also, as an extraordinary force, you have a double agent working at their restaurant poisoning the food and giving all of their customers the runs. Spies and double agents aren’t discussed until later in the book, so I don’t want to get ahead of myself on the use of this idea.

Barbara Darrow and Paula Rooney wrote: http://www.crn.com/it-channel/18830026;jsessionid=4BDWHYYHQTI01QE1GHRSKHWATMY32JVN, back in 2003, how IBM tried to use some extraordinary force against Microsoft. Microsoft has market share for desktop operating systems, but IBM attempted to make office applications available on their servers.

Proper appointment and timing are also applicable to business. All positions must be filled by the most qualified persons. Those that have no talents are excused. All of the strength and facilities of your company should not be used for every business engagement or transaction. The person in charge decides WHEN the best time to exploit an opportunity is and, thus, only requires a portion of the facilities to execute that transaction. An easy example: Your competitor declares bankruptcy, so you capitalize on their weakened position and buy them out. Exploiting an opportunity makes a sizeable acquisition or feat possible with very little effort.

The last discussion is that of Chang Yu’s interpretation of Li Ching’s three situations of war. I can think of how two apply. The first is in respect to morale. A company that has employees that believe in their cause and are loyal to the point of telling all their friends to stay away from the competition would fit this mold. The second is in respect to terrain. The way this is discussed, I can’t, for the life of me, think of a way this applies to business. The third is with respect to the enemy. If your competitor is unorganized and unready for competition, they’re ripe for this situation.

"In the art of war there are no fixed rules"

Sun Tzu starts off his energy section of the book by discussing hierarchy. He explains that the way armies are broken down makes it so commanding many is like commanding few. One of his commentators in the book goes on to break down the actual organizational hierarchy of an army. He also explains that when a large force is deployed, signals must be used to keep them all in contact and cohesion.

I really enjoyed the narrative on normal and extraordinary forces. A normal force is the main offensive. An extraordinary force is, for all intensive purpose, a special force. The extraordinary force is used as a supplement. The first example given is having the normal force engage and having an extraordinary force flank the enemy and, essentially, seal the deal. Sun Tzu uses metaphors of music, colors, and flavors. He says: while you may only have five notes to play, the combination can be melodious. I’m paraphrasing, but, seeing only five colors’ combinations can be infinite, and only five flavors blended can be beyond the perception of taste. I like these comparisons; speaking to different senses. These are the same ways that normal and extraordinary forces must be utilized. Their combination can make infinite winning strategies. Another way they can be used for further deception is to make your enemy think your extraordinary force is normal and your normal force is extraordinary.

Timing is again discussed, as well as proper appointment. Sun Tzu compares an attack to that of a hawk striking it’s prey. If the hawk strikes at just the right time, in just the right way, he is going to break the back of his prey, thus quickly killing it. A military strike must be executed the same way. This is another visit to the idea of prudence.

Proper appointment is obviously necessary, but the burden of victory should not be fully placed on the men. A victory will come from a combination of skill and exploitation of a situation. The valiant fight, the cautious defend, and the wise counsel. Nothing is expected of those who have no talent. The main point here, as I interpret it, is that an army should be strong, but, not all of the strength should have to be used. A general waits for an opportunity in which not all of the strength will be necessary. I believe the way the Air Force puts it is: Be able to do a lot with a little. Again, I’m paraphrasing.

The last discussion is that of Chang Yu’s interpretation of Li Ching’s three situations of war. The first, is a high spirited army who loves to fight and hates their enemy. This is a situation in respect to morale. The second, is few men defending many by advantage of a narrow mountain defile. Their enemy’s are funneled to them. This is a situation in respect to terrain. The third, is catching your enemy off-guard or not ready when they are poorly trained, managed, or what-have-you. This is a situation in respect to the enemy. It's not discussed, but, I think it would be obviously advisable to try to have more than just one of these situations working toward your benefit.

Sunday, October 4, 2009

"The Emporor first asked Tsang Chi for some wine. Tsang Chi sealed up a pot full of urine and sent it to him"

Sun Tzu’s ideas of taking a state intact could easily be equated to taking over a company and using it’s facilities and personnel to further strengthen your own, instead of liquidating it. The idea of fighting being a last resort can equate itself to companies having a symbiotic, or mutually agreed upon merger, as opposed to a hostile takeover.

Going into more detail on that thought; my perceptions of equating these strategies to business get to be, once again, a little underhanded. I will not concede that they are necessarily wrong though. Sun Tzu’s most preferable option of attacking an enemy’s strategy could be a number of things. One could be advertising. The German commercial seen here,

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2966210832320267059&ei=SyPFSprXHp_oqQLMt-Uv&q=burger+king+mcdonalds&hl=en#

shows how Burger King has gone after MacDonald’s for years. That commercial was actually banned after a lawsuit. Another advertising example would be Buick’s new campaign against Lexus. A commercial seen here,

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U50UbFOK5s

attempts to derail the idea of Lexus being the top luxury car brand. Some people might recognize this billboard that’s located on north-bound I-75 coming into Tampa:



The second most preferable option is to disrupt alliances. In business, this could be disrupting your competitor’s supply lines. If your able to convince your competitor’s suppliers to, for some reason, no longer do business with your competitor, you’ve put a serious roadblock in their way. The third most preferable option is to attack their army. The fourth is to attack their cities. Now, in business or interpersonal relationships, I wouldn’t really know how to distinguish between the two. Maybe, in business, your competitor’s army would be their legal division.

The practical equivalent of Sun Tzu’s troop size strategy would be bigger companies buying out smaller companies. There’s not a flawless comparison, though. Sun Tzu discusses what strategy to use when you have five times the troop power of your opponent. Well, if a business is five times bigger than it’s closest competitor, it could easily just buy it’s competitor out. But, it probably wouldn’t because it wouldn’t be worth it. The only time they would want to do that is when there competitor is rapidly growing. When your competitor is stronger, find a weakness or wait for one to present itself, and then capitalize.

The next discussion is that of the general being the protector of the state and keeping the sovereign influence out of the military decision making. In business, distinguishing between the general and the sovereign leader is difficult. It seems to me like the CEO would fill both of those roles. A CFO and other executives and officers, would act as advisers. Decision making, in regards to competition, would rest with the CEO.

Comparing Sun Tzu’s military ideas to more recent events; the first and most obvious one that comes to my mind is the Vietnam War. Sun Tzu stresses that sovereign leaders should be kept out of military decision making. Military decisions should not be made by civilians, politicians, or anyone not wise to the ways of military strategy. Dennis M. Simon’s article “The War in Vietnam, 1965-1968” seen here, http://faculty.smu.edu/dsimon/Change-Viet2.html demonstrates unnecessary sovereign influence on the war. If their wasn’t so much political, public, and media influence on military decision making in favor of approval ratings, the war might have gone very differently. The point is, according to Sun Tzu, the war should have been run by the generals, not by the president.

Getting back to business; there are three things a ruler can do to bring misfortune to the army. Advancing when you shouldn’t, retreating when you shouldn’t, and being ignorant of military affairs. At least two of those ideas can be applied to business. Being more financially aggressive with investment when you don’t have the backing for it will cause much too high of a debt to equity ratio. Being more financially prudent than what you are capable of is going to cause a missed opportunity. Obviously, being overall ignorant of business is going to put a huge strain on your advisors; in which case, they should probably just be running the company in your place. How’d you get there, anyway? Nepotism? That idea doesn’t necessarily apply to business, clearly.

There are five circumstances where victory can be predicted: Knowing when to fight and when not to, knowing how to utilize large and small forces, having united ranks, being prudent, and not being interfered with by the sovereign. The principal of a company should know when to be financially aggressive and when not to, have good morale within a company, and know when not to be aggressive. Being interfered with by the sovereign aligns itself with what I stated earlier. It doesn’t really apply. Knowing how to utilize large and small forces doesn’t always apply either. Normally, when you rank up in business, you wouldn’t find yourself moving back to a position of lesser responsibility. Mercedes and Chrysler were both pretty big before they merged, but obviously one had become weak enough for the other to capitalize. I would argue that this article by Chrysler group, http://www.automotoportal.com/article/daimlerchrysler-to-sell-chrysler-group-to-cerberus puts a positive corporate spin on a situation where those running the show couldn’t handle a consolidated company that big. Then again, it’s probably that the combination of strengths still couldn’t overcome the overwhelmingly weak shortcomings of one under the other. What with the corporate spin, this article is the perfect example of making a big deal seem small.

Sun Tzu concludes with the basic idea of knowing your enemy as well as knowing yourself. This translates to both business and interpersonal relationships. Knowing an opponent or competitor’s strengths and weaknesses allows you to try to avoid those strengths and take advantage of those weaknesses.

"To say that a general must await commands of the sovereign…is like informing a superior that you wish to put out a fire"

The first line of Sun Tzu’s offensive strategy states that taking a state intact is most definitely preferable over destroying it. Great emphasis is put on this idea. To fight is a last resort. Furthermore, what sets apart a good general from a great general is being able to attain victory without killing.

Victory can be attained without fighting. The most preferable option is to attack an enemy’s strategy. Second, is to disrupt alliances. Third is to attack their army. Last, is to attack their cities.

Disrupting alliances makes your enemy much weaker. They have nothing to fall back on but their own resources. It also makes it so they can’t share strategy. This segues into the next idea of troop size strategy. There are two that I think are most interesting. One is, when you have double your opponent’s troops, divide them. That way they can’t discuss unusual strategy. The other, is when you have weaker numbers, to be able to withdraw. There’s still a chance of finding a vulnerability. No matter what the troop size difference, always be able to elude.

The next thing discussed is the idea of the general being the protector of the state. I’m not so sure this should be in the offensive strategy section.

Sun Tzu states there are three things a ruler can do to bring misfortune to the army. One is to advance when they shouldn’t. Another is to retreat when they shouldn’t. Last, is to be ignorant of military affairs. The point here is that civilians or politicians should not be running an army. This confuses the officers and discredits the ruler in their eyes.

According to Sun Tzu, there are five circumstances where victory can be predicted: Knowing when to fight and when not to; understanding how to use large and small forces; having united ranks; being prudent; and, finally, not being interfered with by the sovereign. I’ll be discussing that one further in my next post.

To conclude, know your enemy and know yourself. Knowing just yourself will give you half a chance for victory. Knowing both yourself and your enemy will assure victory. Not understanding either will assure loss.

Sunday, September 27, 2009

"…the general who understands war is the minister of people’s fate and arbiter of the nation’s destiny."

Let’s apply Sun Tzu’s ideas from his “Waging War” section to modern day situations, shall we?

The first thing discussed is provisional and logistical preparation of the unit. Sun Tzu says that the treasury should be empty when going to war. Like I said in my last post, size up your situation before committing all money or energies into any scenario. Only commit what you think it is going to take so you have something to fall back on.

The next thing discussed is speed. Any objective where you have to continually put effort in, you’re going to get wore out. Sometimes it’s hard to tell how long it is going to take to do something. Sun Tzu stresses speed can sometimes be more important than strategy. Obtain your objective as quickly and authoritatively as possible.



A really underhanded idea that is a harsh reality of war is utilizing your defeated enemies’ provisions, facilities, and sometimes personnel. Any practical application of this can almost be like kicking your competitor when they’re down. The most obvious comparison that comes to mind is the merger of companies. One company swallows another and the weaker company is either liquidated or utilized for expansion.

Apparently, Russian companies have taken corporate raiding one step closer to waging war, as illustrated in this article, http://www.cipe.org/blog/?p=3233:

A hostile takeover in Russia has come to mean the redistribution of a company’s ownership through a combination of legal, illegal, and illegitimate means, including forced bankruptcies, the use of administrative resources, raids by police, tax officers, or government inspectors, and even the violent seizure of documents, assets, offices, and places of business

Where the army goes, prices for provisions rise because of higher demand. Alternatively, when a company opens corporate offices in a city, it’s going to boost that city’s economy. Thus, prices will rise for a larger population. There will be fewer resources until the city has a chance to expand to accommodate the company. A real life example would be the University of Florida. Gainesville is a pretty sleepy town. How much do you think their economy depends on the school? A lot.

Treating prisoners humanely is more constructive than treating them poorly. Turn your enemy into a friend. One company takes over another and the weaker company’s personnel should be utilized to strengthen the stronger company further, rather than being fired or laid off.

"War is like unto fire; those who will not put aside weapons are themselves consumed by them"

The next section is titled “Waging War”. Sun Tzu first discusses logistical preparation of military units for war. What equipment, how much equipment, and how many men with which jobs are touched on.

One thing I found interesting was the statement that says the state’s treasury should be empty when the army goes to war. That implies that all of the countries financial resources have been dedicated to the war. That seems short-sighted to me. That puts all your eggs in one basket. If the fight turns into a situation where you have to cut bait, what do you have to go home to? Nothing, that’s what. Part of the preparation, maybe in Estimates, should be sizing up your enemy. Then, knowing how much financial strength the engagement should need.

The big part that stands out for me was the point that war is much easier if it is quick. That is what I based the title quote off of. I interpret the quote as: The longer you fight, the more likely it is you will lose. Speed is sometimes preferable over strategy. Of course, it’s up to the general to decide when that is true. Sun Tzu also states that no country has ever benefited from a protracted war.

Another idea discussed is provisions. Sun Tzu says that, even when preparing, an army should depend on the idea that they are going to take advantage of the resources of their vanquished foes. I can’t say I completely agree with that. I think it is definitely smart to take advantage of those resources and conserve your own. But depending on them is not smart, in my view.

Where the army goes, prices for provisions rise because of higher demand. That can be exemplified by the recent base realignment and closure process that took place in our country a few years ago. A couple of military installations that were in remote locations were slotted for closure. I know of at least one instance where the locals got up in arms, plead their case to state officials and lead to the installation staying open. Their case was that the local economy was so dependent on military members’ money that if the installation closed, the economy would go belly up.

Also, when taking prisoners, Sun Tzu states that they should be treated humanely. Treating them with spite, anger and hatred is not going to be constructive at all. Treating them well might lead them to sympathy and you could turn an enemy into a friend.

Again, I can’t say I completely agree with that. I agree with it to a point. Only in certain situations will it work. The prisoner will have to have been captured from a very disorganized and unpatriotic army or place.

Saturday, September 19, 2009

"All warfare is based on deception," What a sorry apology...



I believe Sun Tzu would never apologize for anything. Thankfully, I’m either a bigger man, not as proud, or am assigned to do so. Take your pick.

One of the reasons I chose to read this book is because I want to be aware of the tactics in case I ever need to use them or I am faced with them. When Sun Tzu’s book is applied to business practice some of the tactics can be very underhanded. I believe it was the movie “The Godfather” where the phrase “It’s just business” was used when they were killing people.

I can’t really apologize for using any of the strategies from the book. I haven’t used them to wrong anyone yet. So, I’ll apologize for reading the book. Hopefully it will be justified when I deeply wrong someone in the future to get ahead in business.

So here is where the apology begins:

To my potential competitors -

I deeply regret having read “The Art of War” by Sun Tzu. It is an evil book and the strategies within should not be used, much less published, or even known of.

I knew it was wrong and I did it anyway. I was wrong because I was looking for a shortcut. That is no way to be. I’ve got to be completely honest from here on in. Any dollar I earn will not be earned without entitlement and hard work. There will be no backstabbing. There will be no taking advantage of a competitor’s weakness. Just a good, clean competition and may the best man win. Even if it’s not me.

Sincerest regrets,
-Horioppo



"With many calculations, one can win; with few one cannot"

All five factors of “Estimates” will not apply to every situation. I find myself having fun with the idea of preparation for anything using the factors. If you prepared for everything using the factors, your life would be wasted on preparation with very little action. Apply the factors to sizeable undertakings or decisions.

What do you want to prepare for? A promotion? Opening a business? A trip or vacation? Some, if not all, of the factors can be applied. Let’s break it down by answering a few questions:

Moral influence:
Promotion: What kind of attitude do you have at work? In what respect do your boss or coworkers see you? Or your boss’ boss?

Business: How would any of your potential suppliers, customers or connections see you? These are people you already know that have a set opinion about you. They will have an opinion about the idea of you opening a business. That opinion will influence their business interactions with you.

Trip: When working with a travel agent or airport attendant, have some patience and be nice. You get more flies with sugar than vinegar, or whatever. You never know what incentives you might be able to grease out of them.

Weather:
Promotion: Weather would loosely be applicable if you had a job working outdoors. Where’s our gardener from class?

Business: Again, unless you’re opening a business where you’re working or storing materials outside, this is not applicable. If it is, open where there are favorable weather conditions.

Trip: Weather is obviously a big factor when traveling. Check the weather channel.

Terrain:
Promotion: Do you meet the criteria for the promotion? Do you possess the technical skills necessary to obtain the promotion?

Business: How tough is the competition in the industry to which you desire to enter? If you foresee competition so fierce that you won’t be able to compete effectively, it’s time to go back to the drawing board. A review of the business version of the book from http://www.amazon.com/Sun-Tzu-Managers-Strategic-Rules/dp/1580624596 gives us this:

"Make an estimate of the situation" and "fight only the battles you can win,"

Trip: Just as an example, if you’re hauling through mountains, does your tow vehicle have enough power?

Command:
Promotion: How confident are you in the job skills that you do have?

Business: How confident and motivated are you to follow-through and see it to the end? Grab that bull!

Trip: How organized and well planned are you? This could be applied to the promotion and business as well.

Doctrine:
Promotion: What is your record like at work? Do you have any dings or demerits on a disciplinary record, if there is such a thing? How well have you followed doctrine passed down from above?

Business: Do you possess all permits and/or licenses or have knowledge of statutes and laws that will apply to your business?

Trip: Do you know the laws for the place you’re traveling to? Know them and follow them. Don’t end up getting beaten with a Singapore cane.

"If a general who refuses to listen to my strategy is employed, he is certain to be defeated. Dismiss him!"

Without getting too specific, I totally agree with the five factors. They are a generalization of many smaller aspects of preparation. From a military aspect, I would categorize them like this: Moral influence would be applied to higher leaders, like presidents; and generals, commanders, and sergeants. Weather and terrain would apply to those that endure it, that is to say, infantry and logistics. Command would apply to generals, commanders, and sergeants. Finally, doctrine would really apply to everyone, but those most concerned with it should be higher leaders and generals.

Moral influence and command are going to be the main determining factors in overall morale. Soldiers that believe in what they’re fighting for will get pride from doing so. They will, therefore, be happy. Moral influence should mainly come from the top of the chain of command, but lateral influence makes for an even tighter knit unit, as sort of exemplified here from http://ldc.upenn.edu/myl/llog/BeetleBaileyMeta.gif :



This illustration also exemplifies discipline, another aspect of both moral influence and command.

Weather and terrain are pretty self explanatory. Harsh weather or natural conditions are going to make battle that much more difficult, obviously. Terrain can be utilized to obtain an advantageous position for ambush or flanking. If it’s not agreeable, it might make for a forced, head-on attack, like on a plain.

Doctrine is something that must be abided by all and enforced by leaders. That’s why I say it concerns everyone.

Next post will be applications of estimates outside of military engagement!

"If a general who heeds my strategy is employed he is certain to win. Retain him!"

In Sun Tzu’s “Estimates” section, he starts off by discussing the unfortunate necessity of war, as well as the necessity of knowing how to proficiently conduct one. The first thing to do is size up five factors. Those factors, in order of importance, are moral influence, weather, terrain, command, and doctrine.

Moral influence refers to”the adequacy of the rulers’ benevolence and the confidence of their peoples,” This is necessary because people won’t fight for something, or in this case, someone, they don’t believe in. A general or president or emperor must gain the favor of their people and show them that there is just cause for a war. They must instill pride and patriotism to justify the risk of death when going into battle. The people have to know they’re fighting for something worthwhile to fight effectively.

The second and third factors are weather and terrain. When weather is first mentioned, I think to myself “How did an ancient Chinese philosopher forecast the weather?” Well, that’s not so much what he’s referring to. When Sun Tzu refers to weather, he means any interaction between man and nature. He bases the norms of a given season and how well they’ll lend themselves to or against a battle or maneuver. Terrain’s importance is very similar. How can the terrain of an engagement lend itself to or against a maneuver? That’s what’s addressed.

The fourth factor is command. To me, this seems very similar to moral influence. Dpioneer of http://www.strategypage.com/militaryforums/30-105846.aspx would agree with me:

It is important to note that two of the five factors mentioned by Sun Tzu, moral influence and command, focus on moral viability concerning war.

Sun Tzu discusses the overall quality of a commander. When I say overall, I don’t just mean his or her quality of strategy, but also their morality, courage, wisdom, and humility. That’s only a few of the characteristics a commander must possess. A commander must have the respect of his or her soldiers and empathy enough to make decisions that put lives on the line.

The fifth factor is doctrine. These are the policies and protocol of the execution of a military engagement. Chain of command, supply chain, and rank structure are addressed.
A couple of examples are then given. If your enemy is prone to provocation, use that. Anger them into making a mistake. My favorite example is to trick your opponent into thinking you’re weak. The example goes like this: a war has not begun yet, but there is a dispute over land. Your opponent keeps requesting concessions from you and you provide them up to a point. You wait until they request something sizeable, with them thinking you’re going to bow down and comply; then you mount a surprise attack. Beautiful.

Sun Tzu finishes up this section by making the point that these factors will be examined before fighting ever begins. When addressing these factors, multiple contingencies must be considered. Plans must be made. If no plans are made, you will be beaten. If many plans are made, you will succeed. Your first plan may be the best one, but all possibilities must be considered.

My next post will be on how much of this I agree with. The following post after that will be how these strategies apply to situations other than military engagements.

Thursday, September 10, 2009

The enemy of my enemy is my friend

I can thank my cousin, who is a retired army lieutenant general, for the title quote for this post. I told him I planned to read Sun Tzu’s “The Art of War” as a blogging project for a writing class. When I asked him if he had read it; that was the quote he fired back at me. The quote was obviously meant to be an adamant, in-your-face, “yes”.
In the following weeks I hope to give my take on what is truly the be all and end all of military strategy. The idea of military strategy from thousands of years ago still followed today intrigues me, but the fact that it can be applied to many, many situations sweetens the deal just that much.
The strategies found therein can be applied, not only to military engagements and contingencies, but to any competitive situation. The most notable application would be the competition of the business world, or any workplace for that matter. I, myself, preparing to step into the business world and being able to relate to strategies applied to my former trade, it seems like a slam dunk to me.
My plan is to read the different sections of the book(it’s not really broken down into distinct chapters,) and write about what I understand it to mean, whether or not or to what degree, I agree with it, and how I believe it to apply to more than just military strategy.
I foresee a very insightful and, hopefully, active discourse. I’ve already read the first section, which I will not discuss at this time. I’ll save it for the next post but I have my set interpretations. I’ve got to say, if it’s not about cars, it is a chore for me to read about it. Such is not the case with this, though. I really feel like I can enjoy this, get passionate about it, and be ready to share and hear others’ opinions on the strategies.