In Sun Tzu’s “Estimates” section, he starts off by discussing the unfortunate necessity of war, as well as the necessity of knowing how to proficiently conduct one. The first thing to do is size up five factors. Those factors, in order of importance, are moral influence, weather, terrain, command, and doctrine.
Moral influence refers to”the adequacy of the rulers’ benevolence and the confidence of their peoples,” This is necessary because people won’t fight for something, or in this case, someone, they don’t believe in. A general or president or emperor must gain the favor of their people and show them that there is just cause for a war. They must instill pride and patriotism to justify the risk of death when going into battle. The people have to know they’re fighting for something worthwhile to fight effectively.
The second and third factors are weather and terrain. When weather is first mentioned, I think to myself “How did an ancient Chinese philosopher forecast the weather?” Well, that’s not so much what he’s referring to. When Sun Tzu refers to weather, he means any interaction between man and nature. He bases the norms of a given season and how well they’ll lend themselves to or against a battle or maneuver. Terrain’s importance is very similar. How can the terrain of an engagement lend itself to or against a maneuver? That’s what’s addressed.
The fourth factor is command. To me, this seems very similar to moral influence. Dpioneer of http://www.strategypage.com/militaryforums/30-105846.aspx would agree with me:
It is important to note that two of the five factors mentioned by Sun Tzu, moral influence and command, focus on moral viability concerning war.
Sun Tzu discusses the overall quality of a commander. When I say overall, I don’t just mean his or her quality of strategy, but also their morality, courage, wisdom, and humility. That’s only a few of the characteristics a commander must possess. A commander must have the respect of his or her soldiers and empathy enough to make decisions that put lives on the line.
The fifth factor is doctrine. These are the policies and protocol of the execution of a military engagement. Chain of command, supply chain, and rank structure are addressed.
A couple of examples are then given. If your enemy is prone to provocation, use that. Anger them into making a mistake. My favorite example is to trick your opponent into thinking you’re weak. The example goes like this: a war has not begun yet, but there is a dispute over land. Your opponent keeps requesting concessions from you and you provide them up to a point. You wait until they request something sizeable, with them thinking you’re going to bow down and comply; then you mount a surprise attack. Beautiful.
Sun Tzu finishes up this section by making the point that these factors will be examined before fighting ever begins. When addressing these factors, multiple contingencies must be considered. Plans must be made. If no plans are made, you will be beaten. If many plans are made, you will succeed. Your first plan may be the best one, but all possibilities must be considered.
My next post will be on how much of this I agree with. The following post after that will be how these strategies apply to situations other than military engagements.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment